MRI scans of 310 men and 280 women at age 18 from the Pune Maternal Nutrition Study showed that abdominal subcutaneous fat (ASAT) carried stronger links to adverse cardiometabolic markers than visceral fat (VAT). Standardised betas ran 0.45 to 0.88 for ASAT versus 0.13 to 0.18 for VAT, covering glucose, lipids, blood pressure, leptin, CRP, leukocyte count, adiponectin and Matsuda insulin sensitivity. ASAT at 18 also predicted risk levels at 24 and the change in those levels, independent of overall obesity and birth size. The pattern challenges the Western narrative that visceral fat is the main driver. In thin-fat South Asian bodies, limited capacity to store fat safely under the skin may make even modest subcutaneous depots metabolically harmful, a plausible reason to question body mass index as the sole yardstick of risk in this population. The study's strengths are MRI quantification, a prospective design and consistency across two time points. Limitations are real: a single rural Indian cohort, no hard outcomes such as diabetes or cardiovascular events, and observational data that cannot prove causation despite the authors' temporality argument. Residual confounding from diet, activity and puberty timing is possible. This is a preprint that has not been peer reviewed, so estimates may shift. For now it is a notable, hypothesis-generating finding rather than a practice-changing one, but it supports earlier metabolic screening, including glucose and lipids, in lean young South Asians.