In 82 postmenopausal women (aged 50-70) who completed an eight-month randomised trial with 98% adherence, ballistic resistance training (maximum-velocity concentric lifts at 20-50% of 1RM, twice weekly) raised total hip BMD by 0.008 g/cm² versus controls. Gains were also seen at the trochanter in women with low baseline BMD. Conventional heavy training (55-80% of 1RM) left hip BMD unchanged but increased tibial shaft cortical BMD and widened the shaft while thinning the cortex.
The result challenges the assumption that heavy loads are the best exercise for the hip. Bone responds to strain rate and impact magnitude as well as load, and fast, explosive movements deliver both at lower weights, which may also make them more tolerable for older adults. Still, the effect is modest: 0.008 g/cm² is roughly 1% of typical hip BMD, and the trial measured density, not fractures. A one-year loss of that size is typical in untreated postmenopausal women, so offsetting it is meaningful, but it will not match drug therapy. The tibial findings are ambiguous; widening of the shaft can improve bending strength even as cortical thickness falls, so the clinical meaning is unresolved. About a quarter of randomised participants dropped out, the women were healthy with mildly low bone density, and the low-BMD subgroup was small. This is a promising, hypothesis-strengthening trial rather than a practice-changing one. Women should consult their clinicians before starting high-velocity training, but this adds support for power-style exercise alongside conventional strength work.